NORTHERN INK JOURNAL / MINING & MARKETS / PERSPECTIVE

Northern Ontario Gold Has a Story Worth Telling

SWISSAID's investigation has put the global gold trade under scrutiny. We put our questions directly to the organization, and its raw materials chief answered. What might that mean for Northern Ontario?

I heard someone the other day say that Timmins doesn't really mine gold anymore. Given our history, and how many of the old mines and headframes have disappeared, I thought it was a nearly fair observation. The truth is, we're still producing a fair bit of gold around here.

In 2025, the Porcupine operations, Timmins West and Bell Creek, and the Fox Complex reported roughly 361,000 ounces of gold production between them. That's more than 11 tonnes in a single year, quand même. Not all of it came from within Timmins city limits. The Porcupine total includes the Borden mine near Chapleau, while the Fox Complex is near Matheson. So we're talking about production across our part of Northern Ontario, not a figure for the city alone.

The industry certainly doesn't look quite the way it once did. Companies have changed hands and some familiar operations have closed. But what happens to the gold we're still producing afterward is something most of us probably don't spend much time thinking about. An international investigation released Thursday gives us a reason to. I had a few questions, so I put them directly to SWISSAID. Marc Ummel, who heads its Raw Materials unit, was generous with his answers.

McIntyre Mine headframe in Timmins

The surviving McIntyre Mine headframe in Timmins, photographed May 19, 2025. Photo: Alpineee / Wikimedia Commons · CC0 1.0.

Swiss development organization SWISSAID estimates that at least 591 tonnes of smuggled or conflict-linked gold entered the United Arab Emirates in 2024. Valued at the gold price on November 1, 2026, that's approximately US$74 billion. The investigation, titled Laundered in the Emirates, examines weaknesses in the international gold trade, particularly among dealers and refiners handling material from Africa and conflict-affected countries.

Some of these trading networks have helped finance armed conflict, while smuggling has deprived producing countries of revenue and oversight. The 591-tonne estimate includes both smuggled and conflict-linked gold. It doesn't mean the entire quantity was stolen or used to finance war, but it does show how much gold can move through international markets without adequate scrutiny of where it came from.

SWISSAID also examined 52 refinery audit reports covering 2023 to 2025. Of these, two were rated fully compliant, 23 compliant with low-risk deviations, 18 noncompliant with medium-risk deviations, and nine noncompliant with high-risk deviations. Several refineries had inadequate records of where their gold originated, while others relied on intermediaries without properly establishing the original source. It's an uncomfortable business, particularly when you consider that gold can pass through several hands before reaching a refinery.

Here was an ounce of gold with a documented Northern Ontario origin, something that isn't always possible once gold enters the international market.

That got me thinking about something that happened much closer to home. In September 2024, the Royal Canadian Mint released a Gold Maple Leaf coin made entirely from gold extracted at Agnico Eagle's Detour Lake mine, northeast of Timmins. The gold was kept separate from other material throughout refining, allowing the Mint to trace the finished product back to Detour Lake. Canadians could even purchase the coin through Costco. Here was an ounce of gold with a documented Northern Ontario origin, something that isn't always possible once gold enters the international market.

Dome Mine in Timmins

The Dome Mine in Timmins, photographed in 2007. Photo: Monogram / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 3.0.

Knowing where gold came from is useful, but it doesn't tell us everything about how it was produced.

A Frenglishman from Timmins asking a Swiss organization about an international gold scandal isn't exactly an everyday occurrence. But that's how it's supposed to work: you ask, and sometimes somebody takes the time to give you a proper answer. Ummel did, despite the investigation having been public for less than a week. He explained that knowing the mine of origin is only part of responsible sourcing. Companies also need to consider the type of gold, how and where it was produced, who supplied it, and whether those checks remain effective over time. “It is not a label that can be attached once and for all to any company, supply chain or country,” he said.

In 2025, Detour Lake underwent external verification under the Mining Association of Canada's Towards Sustainable Mining program. The assessment, conducted by WSP Canada, awarded the operation its highest rating, AAA, in several areas of water management, including water governance and watershed planning. The report describes water monitoring, management practices and engagement with Indigenous partner Nations. Not every category received the highest rating, but the results are publicly available for anyone interested in looking beyond a company's own sustainability statements.

Of course, a favourable assessment doesn't mean something can't go wrong. On August 29 of this year, Detour Lake experienced a tailings-line breach that released tailings and process water. Agnico Eagle reported that the spill was contained, with limited impacts to Easter Creek, and that water quality largely returned to previous conditions within 48 hours. The company also shut down the mill for seven days, replaced the damaged line and strengthened containment measures. Shutting down a mill for a week while repairs and improvements are made is a substantial response, and worth acknowledging. The findings about the environmental impact, including the reported recovery in water quality, remain Agnico Eagle's account of the incident.

Similar external verification reports were completed for Pan American Silver's Timmins West and Bell Creek operations and McEwen's Fox Complex. These assessments look at workplace safety, environmental management, relationships with nearby communities and other responsibilities that come with running a mine. They aren't guarantees of good performance, but they provide a record that can be examined, questioned and compared over time.

There's another part of mining's relationship with Northern Ontario that deserves attention, particularly here in Timmins. Last year, Agnico Eagle contributed $600,000 toward physician recruitment in the city. Together with contributions from the city and Timmins and District Hospital, the funding brought the initiative to $1.8 million, with incentives intended to attract doctors to a community that badly needs them.

“We need incentives, and in my opinion, the industries need to step up,” Agnico Eagle's Ontario vice-president, Andre Leite, told TimminsToday in April 2025.

In July of this year, Lake Shore Gold, a subsidiary of Pan American Silver, donated $350,000 to the Timmins and District Hospital Foundation's campaign for emergency department redevelopment and new medical equipment. That same month, Discovery Mining announced a $5-million partnership with Northern College. Three million dollars will support the Discovery Fieldhouse, while another $2 million will help establish an Environmental Technician program, scheduled to launch in fall 2027.

Those are substantial contributions in a community where healthcare, education and keeping young people in the North are ongoing concerns. If the money helps bring doctors to town and gives students more opportunities close to home, tant mieux. A hospital donation isn't an environmental assessment, and none of these contributions excuses poor mining practices. But they are part of what mining means to communities like Timmins, alongside the jobs, local businesses and responsibilities that come with operating here.

Buyers and refiners are also being asked to show more clearly where their gold comes from. The London Bullion Market Association, which sets standards for refiners participating in the major international bullion market, has been strengthening its sourcing disclosure requirements.

Revised guidance introduced additional public reporting expectations in 2026, including requirements for accredited refiners to identify certain mines supplying their gold. It doesn't mean every mine supplying every refinery must be named, but it does mean more information about the origins of gold is expected to become public. The first round of these disclosures covers 2025 data, with independent assurance of the new disclosures expected to begin with reporting on 2026 data, in 2027. These changes were already underway before SWISSAID released its investigation.

Still, companies already doing much of this work may have less catching up to do as expectations change.

That raises an interesting question for Northern Ontario. Could tighter international standards eventually mean more demand for gold produced here?

Possibly, although I wouldn't start counting on it just yet. If purchasers become more particular about where their gold originates, mines that can document their practices and show where their product goes may have an advantage. Northern Ontario already has examples of that work, from independently assessed mining operations to the Royal Canadian Mint's traceable Detour Lake coin. Canadian refiners may find opportunities as well, particularly if buyers want a clearer account of how their gold moved from the mine to the finished product.

I put the commercial question to Ummel as well. He noted that demand for gold has been strong for years, and buyers already compete for gold from large-scale mines in politically stable countries such as Canada. Broader sanctions on Russian gold could theoretically benefit Canadian producers, he said, but that is different from assuming stricter sourcing rules will automatically favour them. His larger concern was gold sold as “recycled”: evidence suggests some of it has been traded, shipped and melted repeatedly to conceal its true origin. Stronger standards, in his view, need to address that problem.

That doesn't mean gold from Timmins will suddenly fetch a higher price, or that international buyers will automatically favour Canadian producers. Responsible mining operations exist elsewhere, and better documentation can mean additional costs for everyone. Still, companies already doing much of this work may have less catching up to do as expectations change. Whether that leads to greater demand, new business or simply another requirement of doing business internationally remains to be seen. The changes expected in 2027 should give us something to watch, although it may take longer to see what they mean commercially.

Gold-bearing quartz from Hollinger Mine

Gold-bearing quartz from Hollinger Mine, Timmins. Photo: James St. John / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY 2.0.

I don't think Northern Ontario needs to compare itself favourably against miners working in less fortunate parts of the world. Many of those workers are themselves affected by the very trading practices SWISSAID is investigating.

I also asked whether stricter tracing requirements might disadvantage legitimate artisanal and small-scale miners. Ummel said traceability is necessary, but the rules have to suit the kind of mining involved. Most available tools were built for large operations, he noted, and affordable options for smaller miners remain limited. He pointed to government gold-purchasing programs in parts of Africa and Asia as one reason that may begin to change.

What interests me is whether the work being done here, both in mining and refining, will carry greater weight in a market becoming more concerned with where its gold comes from.

We've spent generations producing it. It'll be interesting to see whether the rest of the world starts paying closer attention to how we're doing it.

Sources & Further Reading

Gold production in Northern Ontario

Discovery Mining — Porcupine Operations, 2025 production results

Pan American Silver — 2025 annual reporting, Timmins West and Bell Creek

McEwen — 2025 production results, Fox Complex

International gold sourcing

SWISSAID — Laundered in the Emirates (2026)

SWISSAID — Investigation findings and refinery audit analysis (2026)

Marc Ummel, SWISSAID — responses to questions from Northern INK Journal (November 16, 2026)

Traceability and responsible mining

Royal Canadian Mint — Detour Lake single-mine Gold Maple Leaf announcement (2024)

Mining Association of Canada — Towards Sustainable Mining external verification reports

Detour Lake — WSP external verification summary (2025)

Agnico Eagle — Third-quarter 2026 disclosure, including the Detour Lake tailings-line incident

Community investment

Timmins and District Hospital — Agnico Eagle's $600,000 physician recruitment contribution

TimminsToday — Lake Shore Gold's hospital contribution

Northern College — Discovery Mining's $5-million partnership (July 2026)

International standards

London Bullion Market Association — Responsible Sourcing Programme

London Bullion Market Association — Disclosure Guidance, Version 3 (December 2025)

← Back to Northern INK Journal